"Fourteen Letters From Him"

Abigail is confused about which book to read. Her friend Hannah invites her to a Halloween party, but Abigail prefers to stay home. They go to the party and meet Thomas and Lucas. Lucas challenges Thomas to melt Abigail's heart. Thomas falls in love with Abigail and they start dating. However, Abigail finds out about the challenge and breaks up with Thomas. He apologizes with fourteen letters and Abigail forgives him.